SCIRP (Scientific Research Publishing)是一个出版Junk Science的出版商,其旗下有大量的Junk Science杂志。以前主要出版内容着重于宇宙和物理学,现在又把目光瞄准了医学,其发表了一篇文章Basic Principles Underlying Human Physiology完全暴露了其Junk Science出版商的本色。
Junk Science出版商SCIRP
先来拜读一下这篇题为Basic Principles Underlying Human Physiology惊世骇俗的文章吧。
在文中作者提到了如下内容:
HIV is not etiologically involved in AIDS. It is just a common retrovirus found in AIDS conjuncturally. There is only AIDS that may not be strictly associated neither to a primary immune deficiency nor to an acquired immune deficiency. Actually, heart failure represents the causal factor of AIDS and many other “primary” immune deficiencies (p. 1821).
当时看到我震精了,差点没忍住就射了。神马?艾滋病的病因不是HIV?!心衰才是艾滋病和其他原发性免疫缺陷的病因?
这篇神文被Google搜录了。
更神的是这篇文章只有一篇参考文献。当然爱因斯坦当时写论文的时候也不引用文献,但是现在时代不同了。而且这篇引文也是作者本人自己的。我真是无语了,SCIRP彻底是一个垃圾。
当然,不能因为一篇文章就完全否认SCIRP,该杂志上可能有严谨的科学研究,但是一个严谨的出版商如果这样的文章都能刊登,其质量值得严重怀疑。
SCIRP隶属于China-based Scientific Research,该公司除了SCIRP,还有其他三个商标。
- Scientific Research Publishing
- Hans Publishers, Inc. (HansPub, 汉斯)
- OA Lib (Open Access Library).
- Sophia Publishing Group(该出版商是一个平台,旗下又有如下两个)
Junk Science出版商SCIRP旗下杂志(截止到2014-12-13)
- Advances in Aerospace Science and Technology
- Advances in Aging Research
- Advances in Alzheimer’s Disease
- Advances in Anthropology
- Advances in Applied Sociology
- Advances in Biological Chemistry
- Advances in Bioscience and Biotechnology
- Advances in Breast Cancer Research
- Advances in Chemical Engineering and Science
- Advances in Computed Tomography
- Advances in Entomology
- Advances in Enzyme Research
- Advances in Historical Studies
- Advances in Infectious Diseases
- Advances in Internet of Things
- Advances in Journalism and Communication
- Advances in Linear Algebra & Matrix Theory
- Advances in Literary Study
- Advances in Lung Cancer
- Advances in Materials Physics and Chemistry
- Advances in Microbiology
- Advances in Molecular Imaging
- Advances in Nanoparticles
- Advances in Parkinson’s Disease
- Advances in Physical Education
- Advances in Pure Mathematics
- Advances in Remote Sensing
- Advances in Reproductive Sciences
- Advances in Sexual Medicine
- Agricultural Sciences
- American Journal of Analytical Chemistry
- American Journal of Climate Change
- American Journal of Computational Mathematics
- American Journal of Industrial and Business Management
- American Journal of Molecular Biology
- American Journal of Operations Research
- American Journal of Plant Sciences
- Applied Mathematics
- Archaeological Discovery
- Art and Design Review
- Atmospheric and Climate Sciences
- Beijing Law Review
- Case Reports in Clinical Medicine
- CellBio
- Chinese Medicine
- Chinese Studies
- Circuits and Systems
- Communications and Network
- Computational Chemistry
- Computational Molecular Bioscience
- Computational Water, Energy, and Environmental Engineering
- Creative Education
- Crystal Structure Theory and Applications
- Current Urban Studies
- Detection
- E-Health Telecommunication Systems and Networks
- Energy and Materials for Aerospace Engineering
- Energy and Power Engineering
- Engineering
- Food and Nutrition Sciences
- Forensic Medicine and Anatomy Research
- Geomaterials
- Graphene
- Green and Sustainable Chemistry
- Health
- iBusiness
- InfraMatics
- Intelligent Control and Automation
- Intelligent Information Management
- International Journal of Analytical Mass Spectrometry and Chromatography
- International Journal of Astronomy and Astrophysics
- International Journal of Clean Coal and Energy
- International Journal of Clinical Medicine
- International Journal of Geosciences
- International Journal of Intelligence Science
- International Journal of Internet and Distributed Systems
- International Journal of Medical Physics, Clinical Engineering and Radiation Oncology
- International Journal of Modern Nonlinear Theory and Application
- International Journal of Nonferrous Metallurgy
- International Journal of Organic Chemistry
- International Journal of Otolaryngology and Head & Neck Surgery
- Int’l J. of Communications, Network and System Sciences
- Journal of Agricultural Chemistry and Environment
- Journal of Analytical Sciences, Methods and Instrumentation
- Journal of Applied Mathematics and Physics
- Journal of Behavioral and Brain Science
- Journal of Biomaterials and Nanobiotechnology
- Journal of Biomedical Science and Engineering
- Journal of Biophysical Chemistry
- Journal of Biosciences and Medicines
- Journal of Building Construction and Planning Research
- Journal of Cancer Therapy
- Journal of Computer and Communications
- Journal of Cosmetics, Dermatological Sciences and Applications
- Journal of Crystallization Process and Technology
- Journal of Data Analysis and Information Processing
- Journal of Diabetes Mellitus
- Journal of Electromagnetic Analysis and Applications
- Journal of Electronics Cooling and Thermal Control
- Journal of Encapsulation and Adsorption Sciences
- Journal of Environmental Protection
- Journal of Financial Risk Management
- Journal of Flow Control, Measurement & Visualization
- Journal of Geographic Information System
- Journal of Geoscience and Environment Protection
- Journal of Human Resource and Sustainability Studies
- Journal of Immune Based Therapies, Vaccines and Antimicrobials
- Journal of Information Security
- Journal of Intelligent Learning Systems and Applications
- Journal of Materials Science and Chemical Engineering
- Journal of Mathematical Finance
- Journal of Minerals and Materials Characterization and Engineering
- Journal of Modern Physics
- Journal of Power and Energy Engineering
- Journal of Quantum Information Science
- Journal of Sensor Technology
- Journal of Service Science and Management
- Journal of Signal and Information Processing
- Journal of Software Engineering and Applications
- Journal of Surface Engineered Materials and Advanced Technology
- Journal of Sustainable Bioenergy Systems
- Journal of Textile Science and Technology
- Journal of Transportation Technologies
- Journal of Tuberculosis Research
- Journal of Water Resource and Protection
- Low Carbon Economy
- Materials Sciences and Applications
- Microscopy Research
- Modeling and Numerical Simulation of Material Science
- Modern Chemotherapy
- Modern Economy
- Modern Instrumentation
- Modern Mechanical Engineering
- Modern Plastic Surgery
- Modern Research in Catalysis
- Modern Research in Inflammation
- Natural Resources
- Natural Science
- Neuroscience & Medicine
- New Journal of Glass and Ceramics
- Occupational Diseases and Environmental Medicine
- Open Journal of Accounting
- Open Journal of Acoustics
- Open Journal of Air Pollution
- Open Journal of Anesthesiology
- Open Journal of Animal Sciences
- Open Journal of Antennas and Propagation
- Open Journal of Apoptosis
- Open Journal of Applied Biosensor
- Open Journal of Applied Sciences
- Open Journal of Biophysics
- Open Journal of Blood Diseases
- Open Journal of Business and Management
- Open Journal of Civil Engineering
- Open Journal of Clinical Diagnostics
- Open Journal of Composite Materials
- Open Journal of Depression
- Open Journal of Discrete Mathematics
- Open Journal of Earthquake Research
- Open Journal of Ecology
- Open Journal of Emergency Medicine
- Open Journal of Endocrine and Metabolic Diseases
- Open Journal of Energy Efficiency
- Open Journal of Epidemiology
- Open Journal of Fluid Dynamics
- Open Journal of Forestry
- Open Journal of Gastroenterology
- Open Journal of Genetics
- Open Journal of Geology
- Open Journal of Immunology
- Open Journal of Inorganic Chemistry
- Open Journal of Inorganic Non-metallic Materials
- Open Journal of Internal Medicine
- Open Journal of Leadership
- Open Journal of Marine Science
- Open Journal of Medical Imaging
- Open Journal of Medical Microbiology
- Open Journal of Medical Psychology
- Open Journal of Medicinal Chemistry
- Open Journal of Metal
- Open Journal of Microphysics
- Open Journal of Modelling and Simulation
- Open Journal of Modern Hydrology
- Open Journal of Modern Linguistics
- Open Journal of Modern Neurosurgery
- Open Journal of Molecular and Integrative Physiology
- Open Journal of Nephrology
- Open Journal of Nursing
- Open Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology
- Open Journal of Ophthalmology
- Open Journal of Optimization
- Open Journal of Organ Transplant Surgery
- Open Journal of Organic Polymer Materials
- Open Journal of Orthopedics
- Open Journal of Pathology
- Open Journal of Pediatrics
- Open Journal of Philosophy
- Open Journal of Physical Chemistry
- Open Journal of Political Science
- Open Journal of Polymer Chemistry
- Open Journal of Preventive Medicine
- Open Journal of Psychiatry
- Open Journal of Radiology
- Open Journal of Regenerative Medicine
- Open Journal of Respiratory Diseases
- Open Journal of Rheumatology and Autoimmune Diseases
- Open Journal of Safety Science and Technology
- Open Journal of Social Sciences
- Open Journal of Soil Science
- Open Journal of Statistics
- Open Journal of Stomatology
- Open Journal of Synthesis Theory and Applications
- Open Journal of Therapy and Rehabilitation
- Open Journal of Thoracic Surgery
- Open Journal of Urology
- Open Journal of Veterinary Medicine
- Optics and Photonics Journal
- Pain Studies and Treatment
- Pharmacology & Pharmacy
- Positioning
- Psychology
- Smart Grid and Renewable Energy
- Social Networking
- Sociology Mind
- Soft
- Soft Nanoscience Letters
- Spectral Analysis Review
- Stem Cell Discovery
- Surgical Science
- Technology and Investment
- Theoretical Economics Letters
- Voice of the Publisher
- Wireless Engineering and Technology
- Wireless Sensor Network
- World Journal of AIDS
- World Journal of Cardiovascular Diseases
- World Journal of Cardiovascular Surgery
- World Journal of Condensed Matter Physics
- World Journal of Engineering and Technology
- World Journal of Mechanics
- World Journal of Nano Science and Engineering
- World Journal of Neuroscience
- World Journal of Nuclear Science and Technology
- World Journal of Vaccines
BioPublisher旗下杂志(截止到2014-12-13)
- American Agricultural Research Frontier
- Aquatic Biological Research
- Brewing Journal
- Brewing Research
- Cancer Research and Molecular Diagnostics
- Computational Molecular Biology
- European Research Biotechnology Progress
- Genomics and Applied Biology
- Genomics and Biotechnology
- Genomics and Medical Biology
- Herbal Medicine and Pharmacology Magazine
- Insect Molecular Biology
- Journal of Laboratory Medicine and Quarantine
- Legume Genomics and Genetics
- Marine Biology
- Medical genetics and disease research
- Molecular Plant Breeding
本文编译于:The Chinese Publisher SCIRP (Scientific Research Publishing): A Publishing Empire Built on Junk Science
有这么差吗?学术严谨对于出版社是十分重要的,推荐看看HEALTH这本刊,收录质量不错。
关于期刊杂志社这种东西,我觉得看个人需求吧,每个出版社级别肯定都不一样。而且一两篇你不认同的文章就直接判断这个出版社是垃圾也过于武断了。再者,不是每个人都能在SCI这样级别的期刊发表文章的,不是SCI的期刊就一定是垃圾期刊吗?
我之前在他们那儿发表过文章,体验还行呀,而且也符合我们学校出版文章的需求,顺利毕业了。我觉得不能这样一概而论吧,看自己发表文章的需求,找合适自己的期刊就行了。每本期刊的级别都是不一样的。
我认为仅仅从一句话就大批特批一个出版社也不是很严谨吧,至少需要从多个角度分析,从大量事实出发,才更有说服力。
作为学生毕业需要还是不错的,出版还是很正规的,而且很快满足学校要求,编辑还挺热情认真的。
我觉得这么评价一个出版社是不公平的,可能部分期刊早期确实发表过一些质量不太高的文章,但是我现在在上面近期发布的一些新文章,质量是有显著的提高的。而且有些作者看的出来是长期合作,我想这确实是对这个出版社,至少是他经常投稿的期刊的质量是认可的。